All Recipes
About Sarah Contact
Indiana Sugar Cream Pie Recipe 30 min recipe 8 servings custard pies dessert easy baking holiday desserts midwestern desserts old-fashioned recipes pies vintage recipes Apr 16, 2025

This pie has a quiet kind of charm. No fruit, no fancy topping, no complicated crust — just a creamy, custard-like filling nestled in a flaky shell and dusted with a hint of nutmeg. It’s called Sugar Cream Pie, and it’s been comforting Indiana kitchens for generations.

I first tried it when my neig...

Continue Reading...

All My Recipes

Author

Sarah Miller

Mom. Real food lover. Dinner-time survivor.

I’m Sarah, a 41-year-old mom who used to feel tired, bloated, and stuck. After struggling with my body and meals for years, I finally found simple, healthy dinners that helped me feel good again. Now I share them with other women who want the same.